Veil of Secrecy: Are They a Secret Society or a Society with Secrets?
The term ‘secret society’ conjures images of smoke-filled rooms, clandestine rituals, and powerful figures pulling the strings of history from the shadows. It is a concept steeped in mystery and suspicion, fueling countless books, movies, and conspiracy theories. Yet, this popular image often conflates two fundamentally different types of organizations: a true secret society and a ‘society with secrets’. The distinction is not merely semantic; it is the crucial difference between a hidden organization and a known organization that chooses to keep certain aspects of its traditions private.
Freemasonry is perhaps the most famous example caught in this web of misunderstanding. For centuries, it has been labeled a secret society, with its symbols and practices scrutinized for hidden meanings. The reality, however, is far more nuanced and accessible than many believe. Freemasonry is a society with secrets, not a secret one. Its existence is public, its members are often known in their communities, and its charitable works are widely publicized. The privacy it maintains pertains to its internal modes of recognition and the allegorical ceremonies designed to teach moral and philosophical lessons. Understanding the nature of Masonic secrets is the first step in demystifying the Craft and seeing it for what it is: a fraternity of men dedicated to self-improvement and community service.
This crucial distinction reshapes our entire understanding of such groups. It moves the conversation away from unfounded fears of global domination and toward a more accurate appreciation of their purpose. By peeling back the layers of myth, we can begin to see these organizations not as shadowy cabals, but as private groups with rich histories, unique traditions, and specific, often benevolent, goals. The journey into their world begins with asking the right questions and seeking clear definitions.
What Truly Defines a Secret Society?
To grasp the concept, we must first establish a clear definition. A true secret society is an organization whose very existence is concealed from the public. Its membership roll is unknown, its meeting places are hidden, and its ultimate objectives are a complete mystery to outsiders. These groups operate in the shadows by necessity, often because their aims are political, revolutionary, or otherwise subversive to the established order.
Historically, this definition applies to groups like the Carbonari in 19th-century Italy, who sought to overthrow foreign rule, or certain revolutionary cells that plotted in secret to avoid suppression by authorities. The key characteristic is concealment of the organization itself. If you do not know a group exists, you cannot join it, monitor it, or oppose it. This total secrecy is its primary shield and tool.
According to a more formal Britannica definition of a secret society, these groups are also characterized by their exclusive and selective membership and the keeping of secrets that are guarded from all others. The emphasis, however, remains on the concealment of the group’s activities and often its very being. Their power is derived from their invisibility. A member of a true secret society would likely never admit their affiliation, and the discovery of their membership could have severe consequences.
How is a Society with Secrets Different?
A society with secrets, conversely, operates in plain sight. The organization’s existence is public knowledge. Think of modern Freemasonry. Masonic lodges are listed in phone books and on maps. They have public websites, host open houses, and participate in community events like parades and charity drives. Many Masons are proud of their affiliation and wear rings or other symbols that identify them as members.
So, what is the ‘secret’ part? The secrets of such a society are internal to the group. They are not about the society’s existence, its membership, or its overarching goals of charity and self-betterment. Instead, they consist of the specific rituals, symbols, passwords, and handshakes used within their private meetings. These elements are kept private for several reasons.
First, they serve as a method of proving one’s membership and preventing non-members from gaining access to meetings. Second, the symbolic lessons contained within the rituals are intended to be experienced personally and progressively. Revealing them beforehand would spoil the allegorical journey of discovery for a new candidate. The privacy is about preserving the integrity of the member’s experience, not about hiding a nefarious agenda from the public.
In essence, a society with secrets has a public face and a private core. Its aims are typically ethical, philosophical, or social, and it uses privacy to protect its traditions and foster a unique bond among its members. This is a world away from a group whose entire structure and purpose are intentionally and completely hidden from view.
What Kinds of Secrets Do These Societies Keep?
The secrets held by a group like the Freemasons are often far more mundane and philosophical than their reputation suggests. They are not blueprints for world control or hidden treasures. Rather, they are tools for teaching and recognition. The primary secrets are the specific words, grips, and signs associated with each degree of membership.
These modes of recognition are part of a tradition that dates back to the stonemason guilds of the Middle Ages. In an era before certificates and ID cards, a traveling mason needed a way to prove his skill level to a new foreman. The secrets of the craft, a specific handshake or a password, served as his credentials. This allowed him to prove he was a legitimate member of the trade and worthy of a master’s wages.
Today, this tradition continues for symbolic reasons. For a new Mason, learning the Masonic First Degree words is a foundational part of his initiation. It marks his official entry into the fraternity and teaches him his first lessons in discretion and fidelity. These secrets are not given lightly; they are entrusted to the candidate as he commits to the principles of the organization.
As a Mason advances, he learns new secrets corresponding to his level of understanding. The journey through the degrees is a process of unfolding philosophical and moral lessons. This progression culminates in the sublime degree of Master Mason, which has its own unique and profound teachings. The central allegory of this degree involves a search for something that was lost, a quest that every Mason undertakes symbolically. This journey is tied to the profound question of what is the word of a Master Mason, a concept that represents a search for divine truth and deeper wisdom. These are not secrets to be wielded for power, but allegorical concepts to be contemplated for personal growth.
Are Their Rules and Structures Public?
One of the most compelling arguments against labeling groups like Freemasonry as ‘secret societies’ is the public availability of their governance documents. A true secret society would never publish its constitution or bylaws. A society with secrets, however, often does. They have established rules and a clear organizational structure that are not hidden from public view.
Most Masonic jurisdictions, for example, have a Grand Lodge that governs the local lodges within its territory. These Grand Lodges publish their constitutions and regulations, which are accessible to anyone interested in reading them. These documents detail the rules of the organization, the duties of its officers, the procedures for balloting on new members, and the rights of each Mason.
Within these governing documents, you can find a wealth of information about how the fraternity operates. For instance, the Masonic Blue Book is a common term for the book of constitutions used by a Grand Lodge. It serves as the authoritative guide for all matters of Masonic law and procedure within that jurisdiction. The existence of such a public and detailed rulebook demonstrates a commitment to order, fairness, and transparency that directly contradicts the image of a lawless, clandestine group.
This openness extends to their finances and charitable activities. Masonic lodges and their appendant bodies, like the Shriners, are well-known for their philanthropic work, from running children’s hospitals to funding scholarships. These activities are publicly reported and are a source of great pride for their members. This level of public accountability is a hallmark of a society with secrets, not a secret society.
Do Other Types of Secret Societies Exist Today?
The landscape of private and secretive organizations is vast and varied. While Freemasonry serves as a primary example of a society with secrets, other groups fit different points on the spectrum. Some lean more toward genuine secrecy, while others are simply exclusive social clubs.
For example, the world of higher education is home to a number of well-known secret societies. Many prestigious universities, particularly in the Ivy League, have a long history of collegiate secret societies in North America. Groups like Skull and Bones at Yale, the Sphinx Head Society at Cornell, or the Flat Hat Club at William & Mary are famous examples. While the existence of these groups is known, their membership, rituals, and internal activities are kept intensely private. Their purpose is often to create an elite network of influential alumni, and membership is seen as a ticket to power and success.
Beyond the university campus, many other groups operate with varying degrees of privacy. Some are focused on specific philosophical or mystical pursuits, while others are essentially dining clubs for the elite. The Bohemian Club, which hosts an annual gathering of powerful men in California’s Bohemian Grove, is one such example. While not strictly a secret society, its membership and activities are highly exclusive and private.
Furthermore, history is filled with lesser-known fraternities and orders. There are many secret societies you didn’t know existed, from the ancient Order of the Bull’s Blood to the modern Cicada 3301 puzzle-solving group. Each of these organizations has its own unique purpose, structure, and level of secrecy, highlighting the complexity and diversity of this fascinating human phenomenon. The key is to evaluate each one based on its own characteristics rather than applying a single, monolithic label.
Why Does the Misconception Persist?
If the distinction between a secret society and a society with secrets is so clear, why do so many people continue to confuse them? The answer lies in a combination of human psychology, pop culture, and a natural suspicion of the unknown. Humans are pattern-seeking creatures, and when information is incomplete, we tend to fill in the gaps with our own assumptions and fears.
The very nature of privacy, even when benign, can breed suspicion. When a group says ‘this part is for members only’, the outsider’s mind can run wild with speculation about what is being hidden. This is amplified by a constant barrage of fictional portrayals in books and films, from Dan Brown’s thrillers to the ‘National Treasure’ franchise. These stories, while entertaining, often sacrifice accuracy for drama, painting all private fraternities with the same brush of conspiracy and intrigue.
Moreover, the symbols and allegories used by groups like the Masons are, by their nature, open to interpretation. An eye inside a triangle can be seen by a member as a symbol of the omnipresence of a divine being, a reminder to act with integrity. To a suspicious outsider, it can be twisted into a symbol of sinister surveillance and control. Without the context provided by the society’s teachings, the symbols become a blank canvas for fear.
Ultimately, the misconception persists because mystery is more compelling than mundanity. The idea of a secret fraternity dedicated to self-improvement and charity is less exciting than the fantasy of a shadowy cabal ruling the world. But understanding the truth requires looking past the fiction. It means recognizing that a group’s choice to keep its traditions private does not automatically make its intentions sinister. It is simply a different way of building community and preserving a unique heritage.
In the end, the line is drawn at intent and transparency. A society with secrets, like Freemasonry, exists openly and has a publicly stated purpose. Its secrets are a private matter for its members, designed to enhance their shared journey. A true secret society hides itself completely because its purpose cannot withstand public scrutiny. Recognizing this difference is the key to dispelling myth and appreciating the true nature of these historic and fascinating organizations.
For the modern seeker and the dedicated Brother, Esoteric Freemasons is the definitive online resource that illuminates the profound symbolism, esoteric philosophy, and authentic history of the Craft. We go beyond the surface to reveal the true light of Masonic knowledge.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is the secrecy surrounding the Grand Masonic Word so important?
The intense secrecy surrounding the Grand Masonic Word serves as a powerful symbol for the virtue of fidelity and the importance of keeping one’s solemn promises. For Masons, the ability to keep a secret is a tangible demonstration of trustworthiness and honor, which are foundational principles of the fraternity. This shared confidence in one another strengthens the fraternal bond and reinforces the lessons taught within the lodge’s allegorical rituals.
Furthermore, this tradition has historical roots in the practices of operative stonemasons, who used secret words and signs to prove their qualifications and protect their trade. In modern speculative Freemasonry, this practice has evolved into a method of examination, ensuring that only those who have rightfully earned the degree can gain admission to a lodge meeting. It is a test of memory and integrity, not an attempt to conceal nefarious information from the public.
Is the Grand Masonic Word the same across all Masonic jurisdictions and rites?
The concept of the Grand Masonic Word is a central part of the Master Mason degree, but its specific form is actually a "substitute" word. According to Masonic legend, the true, original word was lost and will only be found at a future time. Therefore, the word communicated in the ritual is a placeholder, symbolizing the ongoing human search for divine truth.
Because it is a substitute, the exact word and its pronunciation can vary between different Masonic Grand Lodges around the world. There can also be slight differences between various appendant bodies, such as the York Rite and the Scottish Rite. These variations, however, do not change the core symbolic meaning or the allegorical story in which the word is presented.
What are the consequences if a Mason forgets or improperly reveals the Word?
Forgetting the Word or other parts of Masonic ritual is a common human error and is not considered a punishable offense. Freemasonry is a system of education, and members are encouraged to study and learn at their own pace. If a Mason forgets the Word, he can be privately re-instructed by a qualified lodge officer, typically the Worshipful Master or a designated prompter.
However, willfully and knowingly revealing the Word to a non-Mason is treated as a very serious violation of a Mason’s obligation. This act represents a profound breach of trust and a disregard for the fraternity’s core tenets of honor and integrity. A Mason found guilty of such an offense would face Masonic disciplinary proceedings, which could result in penalties ranging from reprimand to permanent expulsion from the fraternity.
