Beyond the Brotherhood: Unveiling the Role of Women in Freemasonry
When most people picture a Freemason, they imagine a man in an apron, a member of a centuries-old secret society steeped in tradition and brotherhood. This image, while historically accurate for mainstream Freemasonry, paints an incomplete picture of the modern Masonic world. The relationship between women and the Craft is far more complex, nuanced, and evolving than many realize, with a rich history of its own.
The conversation often begins and ends with the perception of exclusion. However, a deeper look reveals a landscape where women actively participate in Masonic traditions, rituals, and philosophy. Understanding the existence and legitimacy of female Masons is the first step toward appreciating the full spectrum of the Masonic experience today. These are not mere social clubs but dedicated bodies practicing the same symbolic work of self-improvement.
This journey into the role of women in Freemasonry is not about rewriting history but about revealing the chapters that are often overlooked. It is an exploration of parallel paths, mutual respect, and a shared quest for light. From historical anomalies to the rise of dedicated women’s and co-ed Grand Lodges, the story is one of adaptation and dedication to core Masonic principles.
What is the Historical Context of Freemasonry and Women?
To understand the present, we must first look to the past. Freemasonry as we know it today, often called speculative Masonry, evolved from the guilds of operative stonemasons who built Europe’s great cathedrals and castles. These guilds, flourishing in the late Middle Ages, were almost exclusively male due to the physical nature of the work and the societal structures of the time.
As the great age of cathedral building waned, these lodges began accepting non-operative members, men of learning and social standing interested in the guild’s moral and philosophical teachings. This shift culminated in the formation of the first Grand Lodge in London in 1717. A few years later, in 1723, James Anderson published his Constitutions, a foundational document for modern Freemasonry.
Anderson’s Constitutions stipulated that Masons must be ‘good and true Men, free-born, and of mature and discreet Age’. At the time, the term ‘Men’ was taken literally, and the requirement of being ‘free’ meant a man was not a serf or bondsman and was his own master. In the 18th-century context, this effectively excluded women, who had limited legal and economic independence.
This foundation established the tradition of Freemasonry as a fraternity, a brotherhood of men. This was not born of malice but was a reflection of the patriarchal society in which it was formalized. The lodge became a space for men outside the home and church, a unique environment for fellowship and esoteric education.
Are There Exceptions to the ‘Men-Only’ Rule in History?
Despite the formal rules, history is rarely without its fascinating exceptions. The most famous and well-documented case is that of Elizabeth Aldworth, known as ‘The Lady Freemason’. Born in 1695 in Ireland, she was the daughter of the Viscount Doneraile. The story holds that she secretly witnessed the proceedings of a Masonic lodge meeting being held in her family home.
After being discovered, the members of the lodge faced a dilemma. Elizabeth had learned secrets she was not supposed to know. After much deliberation, they chose a remarkable solution: to initiate her into the Craft. This would bind her by the same Masonic oath of secrecy that they had all taken. Aldworth reportedly remained a respected Mason in good standing for the rest of her life, a unique anomaly in Masonic history.
While Aldworth’s case is the most celebrated, other stories exist, though they are often less substantiated. One such account involves Hélène, Countess Hadik Barkóczy de Szala, in Hungary, who was reportedly initiated in the 19th century into a lodge under a special charter. These instances, though rare, show that the ‘rules’ were occasionally interpreted with a degree of flexibility when faced with extraordinary circumstances.
These historical footnotes are important because they demonstrate that the boundary was not as absolute as modern perceptions might suggest. They represent early cracks in a monolithic tradition, hinting at the possibility of a different future for the Craft, one that could eventually include women on a more formal and widespread basis.
How Did Co-Freemasonry Emerge?
The most significant shift in the relationship between women and Freemasonry occurred in the late 19th century, a period of great social and intellectual change. It was during this time that movements for women’s suffrage and esoteric spiritualism were gaining momentum, creating a fertile ground for new ideas about equality and universalism.
The birth of what is now known as Co-Freemasonry took place in France. In 1882, a French lodge, ‘Les Libres Penseurs’ (The Free Thinkers), initiated Maria Deraismes, a prominent writer, orator, and advocate for women’s rights. This act was considered highly irregular by their governing body, the Grand Loge Symbolique Écossaise, which promptly suspended the lodge’s charter.
Undeterred, Deraismes, along with the influential Mason Georges Martin, worked for over a decade to establish a Masonic body that would formally and equally admit both men and women. In 1893, they founded La Grande Loge Symbolique Écossaise ‘Le Droit Humain’ (The Human Right). This was a revolutionary step, creating the first Masonic Obedience that was open to all of humanity without distinction of gender, race, or religion.
Le Droit Humain quickly grew into an international organization, spreading its vision of universal brotherhood and sisterhood across the globe. This movement established a clear and legitimate pathway for women to become Masons, practicing the same ancient rituals and embracing the same philosophical journey. It provided an answer to the question of what are female Masons by creating an institution where they were simply Masons, equal in every respect to their male counterparts.
What are the Different Types of Masonic Bodies for Women?
Today, the landscape of Freemasonry for women is diverse, with several distinct types of organizations. They all share a common Masonic heritage but differ in their membership policies. Understanding these differences is key to grasping the full picture.
First, there is Co-Freemasonry, as pioneered by Le Droit Humain. These are mixed-gender lodges where men and women are initiated and work together as equals. They operate under their own international Grand Lodges and are present in many countries around the world, offering a fully integrated Masonic experience.
Second, and increasingly prominent, are women-only Grand Lodges. These bodies are exclusively for women and operate in a manner that is parallel to traditional male-only Grand Lodges. They practice the same rituals, follow the same constitutions, and uphold the same landmarks of the Craft. In the United Kingdom, for example, the Honourable Fraternity of Ancient Freemasons (HFAF), founded in 1913, and the Order of Women Freemasons (OWF), founded in 1908, are two large and respected women-only Grand Lodges. They provide a space for women to experience the sororal bonds of Freemasonry, much like men experience the fraternal bonds. When considering the question of what are female Masons called, members of these orders are simply Freemasons or Masons.
Finally, there are appendant or adoptive bodies, which are connected to mainstream male Freemasonry but are not considered ‘the Craft’ itself. The most well-known of these is the Order of the Eastern Star, open to Master Masons and their female relatives. These organizations have their own beautiful rituals and charitable missions but are auxiliary to the main Masonic lodges rather than being Masonic lodges themselves. For a comprehensive historical and organizational overview, the Wikipedia page on Freemasonry and women offers a detailed resource.
What is the Stance of Mainstream Grand Lodges Today?
The relationship between ‘mainstream’ or ‘regular’ Freemasonry, as represented by bodies like the United Grand Lodge of England (UGLE), and women’s Freemasonry is one of mutual respect but formal separation. The concept of ‘regularity’ is central here. For UGLE and the many Grand Lodges in amity with it, a key requirement for recognition is that a lodge must trace its lineage back to the original Grand Lodges of Britain and adhere strictly to the ancient landmarks, including the male-only membership rule.
Because women’s and co-masonic Grand Lodges were founded later and do not adhere to the male-only rule, they are not formally ‘recognized’ by UGLE. This means that members cannot visit each other’s lodge meetings or officially interact in a Masonic capacity. However, this lack of formal recognition does not equate to hostility or denial of their legitimacy.
In 1999, the UGLE issued a landmark statement clarifying its position. It acknowledged that women’s Grand Lodges, like the OWF and HFAF, are regular in their practice. The statement affirmed that while UGLE lodges are for men, ‘discussions with the women’s Grand Lodges have been most cordial and constructive’. This perspective is shared by many, as discussed in articles about Freemasonry and women from a lodge’s viewpoint. The UGLE has a clear page outlining its perspective on women Freemasons, which confirms this position of respectful co-existence.
This means that while a man cannot join a women’s lodge and a woman cannot join a UGLE lodge, the organizations view each other as part of the same broader Masonic family, working in parallel towards similar goals. This modern understanding reflects a significant evolution from the rigid exclusions of the past, as further explored in thoughtful analyses like Martin Sparks’ essay on Freemasonry and women.
What are the Core Principles and Duties Shared by All Masons?
Beyond the debates about gender and recognition lies a profound common ground. Whether in a men’s lodge, a women’s lodge, or a co-masonic lodge, the fundamental purpose and principles of Freemasonry remain the same. The journey is one of moral and spiritual development, veiled in allegory and illustrated by symbols.
The core tenets are universal. A belief in a Supreme Being, a guiding creative principle in the universe, is a primary requirement. This is not tied to any specific religion but is a foundation for the moral framework of the Craft. Freemasonry teaches its members to be good citizens, to practice charity, and to act with integrity and compassion in all aspects of their lives.
The central allegory of Freemasonry revolves around the building of King Solomon’s Temple. Masons use the tools of the stonemason, like the square, compasses, and gavel, as symbols to teach moral lessons. The goal is to work on one’s own ‘rough ashlar’, or imperfect character, and transform it into a ‘perfect ashlar’, a more virtuous and enlightened self fit for the ‘temple’ of humanity.
These principles mean the essential duties of a Mason are consistent across all forms of the Craft. They include a duty to God (as each member understands Him), a duty to one’s neighbor through charity and service, and a duty to oneself through the pursuit of knowledge and self-improvement. This shared mission to ‘make good people better’ is the true heart of Freemasonry, and it is a mission that transcends gender.
Why is the Topic Still a Subject of Debate?
Given the existence of respected women’s and co-masonic bodies, some may wonder why the ‘men-only’ rule persists in mainstream Freemasonry and remains a topic of discussion. The answer lies in a complex interplay of tradition, identity, and organizational philosophy.
For traditionalists, Freemasonry’s identity as a brotherhood is a vital and defining characteristic. They argue that the single-gender environment creates a unique type of bond and open communication, which would be fundamentally altered by admitting women. For them, this is not about superiority or exclusion but about preserving the specific character and historical continuity of their institution. They maintain that women are free to have their own parallel Masonic experience in their own lodges, which they respect.
On the other side of the debate, progressives argue that in the 21st century, any form of gender-based exclusion is outdated and contrary to the Masonic principle of universalism. They believe that for Freemasonry to remain relevant and truly embody its ideals of equality, it must adapt to modern societal norms and embrace inclusivity. They point to the success of co-masonic lodges as proof that a mixed-gender environment can thrive without sacrificing Masonic principles.
This is not a simple argument with a right or wrong answer. It is an ongoing conversation within the global Masonic community. Both sides are typically composed of well-intentioned people who care deeply about the Craft and its future. The existence of different types of Masonic bodies allows individuals to choose the environment that best suits their personal beliefs and needs, whether that is a fraternity, a sorority, or a fully integrated community.
The story of women in Freemasonry is not one of exclusion, but of evolution. It has moved from historical anomaly to the creation of parallel and respected institutions. Today, hundreds of thousands of women around the world practice the Craft, pursuing the same light and wisdom as their male counterparts. The relationship between the different branches of the Masonic family continues to develop, guided by a shared respect for the timeless principles that lie at the heart of the square and compasses.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are female Masons considered ‘regular’ or ‘recognized’ Freemasons?
This is a complex issue rooted in Masonic tradition, as the definition of "regularity" is typically set by mainstream, male-only Grand Lodges. From their perspective, female-only or co-ed Masonic orders are not officially recognized as part of regular Freemasonry. Therefore, a female Mason cannot visit a lodge under a body like the United Grand Lodge of England (UGLE) or most state Grand Lodges in the US.
Despite this, women’s and Co-Masonic orders consider themselves to be Masonically regular because they follow the ancient landmarks, rituals, and principles of the Craft. While formal recognition is withheld by the male-only bodies, some, including the UGLE, acknowledge their existence and share aims of building good character and serving humanity. The distinction is one of formal inter-relations and visitation rights, not necessarily the legitimacy of the Masonic work being performed.
What is the difference between Co-Masonry and the Order of the Eastern Star?
The fundamental difference is that Co-Masonry is a form of Freemasonry, while the Order of the Eastern Star (OES) is a Masonic-related appendant body. Co-Masonic orders, like Le Droit Humain, initiate both men and women as Freemasons, conferring the three symbolic degrees of Entered Apprentice, Fellowcraft, and Master Mason. Their members are considered Masons who practice the same core rituals and follow the same philosophical system as those in single-gender lodges.
The Order of the Eastern Star, by contrast, is an associated organization with its own unique rituals, lessons, and structure separate from Craft Masonry. Its membership is open to Master Masons and their female relatives, but it does not make its female members Freemasons. The OES is a vital part of the wider Masonic family, promoting charity and fraternity, but it is not a Masonic lodge itself.
Can a woman join any Masonic lodge she wants?
No, a woman cannot join just any Masonic lodge, as the vast majority of lodges worldwide are part of "regular" Grand Lodges that are exclusively for men. These organizations do not accept petitions from women, adhering to a long-standing tradition of being a male-only fraternity. Attempting to join one of these lodges would not be possible for a female applicant.
However, a woman who wishes to become a Freemason can join specific organizations established for that purpose. She would need to seek out either a women-only Grand Lodge, such as the Honourable Fraternity of Ancient Freemasons (HFAF), or a Co-Masonic order that admits both men and women. These bodies operate independently from the male-only mainstream but offer a complete and authentic Masonic experience for their members.
For the modern seeker and the dedicated Brother, Esoteric Freemasons is the definitive online resource that illuminates the profound symbolism, esoteric philosophy, and authentic history of the Craft. We go beyond the surface to reveal the true light of Masonic knowledge.
