Beyond the Brotherhood: A Modern Look at Women and Freemasonry
When most people picture a Freemason, the image that comes to mind is often a man in formal attire, a member of a centuries-old fraternity steeped in tradition and secrecy. For much of its history, this picture was largely accurate. The Craft, as it is known, was a homosocial space, a brotherhood intended for men. Yet, this traditional image only tells part of a much more complex and evolving story.
The conversation around Freemasonry is changing. Today, the question of gender is no longer a simple ‘men only’ answer. A rich and vibrant history of women’s involvement in Masonic thought and practice has been unfolding for centuries, leading to the establishment of legitimate and thriving Masonic bodies for women. Understanding the world of female masons requires looking beyond the surface of mainstream Freemasonry and exploring a parallel path of enlightenment and fellowship.
This journey reveals a landscape far more diverse than many realize. It includes co-masonic orders that welcome both men and women, as well as Grand Lodges established exclusively for women that practice the same rituals and uphold the same values as their male counterparts. The story of women in Freemasonry is not one of intrusion but of parallel development, mutual respect, and a shared pursuit of light.
Why was Freemasonry traditionally for men?
To understand why women were historically excluded, we must travel back to the origins of the Craft. Freemasonry grew out of the guilds of operative stonemasons, the skilled artisans who built the great cathedrals and castles of Europe. These were physically demanding trades, and the guilds were exclusively male environments, a common reality for nearly all professions at the time.
As these guilds transitioned from operative work to speculative philosophy in the 17th and 18th centuries, they retained their foundational structure. The early speculative lodges, which focused on moral and spiritual development using the tools of stonemasonry as allegories, inherited the all-male character of their operative predecessors. The language, symbolism, and rituals were developed within this context, creating a fraternal, or brotherly, bond.
The social norms of the era were a powerful reinforcing factor. Public and civic life was dominated by men, and fraternal organizations like Freemasonry reflected this societal structure. The ‘charges’ and ‘constitutions’ written to govern the new speculative Craft, like Anderson’s Constitutions of 1723, explicitly stated that Masons should be ‘good and true Men, free-born, and of mature and discreet Age’. This set a precedent that would define mainstream Freemasonry for the next two centuries.
This foundation is crucial to understanding the modern landscape. The traditional, or regular, Grand Lodges around the world, which trace their lineage back to this period, maintain the all-male requirement as a point of historical and traditional continuity. It is not seen by them as a statement on the worth or capability of women, but as an adherence to the foundational rules that define their specific branch of Freemasonry.
How did women first enter the Masonic world?
Despite the formal rules, the allure of Masonic philosophy was not lost on women. The first significant development occurred in 18th-century France with the rise of ‘Lodges of Adoption’. These were quasi-Masonic bodies sponsored by regular male lodges, created for the female relatives of their members.
While members of Adoption Lodges were not considered Masons in the same sense as their male counterparts, they participated in rituals and explored moral teachings that were heavily inspired by Freemasonry. The symbolism was adapted, often drawing from biblical heroines and classical virtues. This system provided a structured social and philosophical outlet for women that was connected to, yet distinct from, the main fraternity.
There are also a few legendary, albeit exceptional, cases of women being initiated into traditional male lodges. The most famous is Elizabeth Aldworth, the ‘Lady Freemason’ of Ireland. The story goes that in the early 1710s, she secretly witnessed a lodge meeting being held in her father’s house. Upon being discovered, the lodge members decided the best way to secure her silence was to initiate her, which they did. She remained a respected member for the rest of her life.
These early instances were anomalies, not the norm. They did, however, demonstrate that the core principles of Masonry were not inherently gender-specific. The seeds were planted for a more organized and independent form of female Freemasonry that would emerge later, one that sought not just an auxiliary role but full and equal participation in the Masonic tradition.
What are Co-Masonic and Women-Only Grand Lodges?
The late 19th and early 20th centuries marked a pivotal turning point. This era saw the birth of two distinct models for women’s full Masonic participation: Co-Masonry, which admits both men and women, and women’s-only Freemasonry.
The most prominent Co-Masonic body is The International Order of Freemasonry for Men and Women, Le Droit Humain. Founded in France in 1893, it was born from a desire for universal brotherhood that transcended gender, religion, and race. Its founders believed that denying women full Masonic rights was contrary to the very principles of equality and liberty that Masonry espoused. Le Droit Humain quickly spread, establishing a significant presence worldwide, including in the UK and the Americas. It practices the Craft with the same rigor and depth as any traditional lodge, conferring the three degrees of Entered Apprentice, Fellow Craft, and Master Mason upon all its members, regardless of gender. The international scope of this movement is a testament to its enduring vision of a truly masonic women-freemasonry that embraces all.
At the same time, another movement was gaining momentum, one that believed in creating a unique Masonic space specifically for women. This led to the formation of women’s-only Grand Lodges. In the United Kingdom, two main bodies were established: The Order of Women Freemasons (OWF) and The Honourable Fraternity of Ancient Freemasons (HFAF). Founded in 1908 and 1913 respectively, these organizations were created by women, for women.
They adopted the same rituals, constitutions, and principles as the United Grand Lodge of England (UGLE), the governing body for male Freemasons in England. Their aim was not to alter Freemasonry but to practice it authentically in a single-gender environment, much like the men’s lodges. They argue that this structure allows women to develop and lead without the societal dynamics that can sometimes arise in mixed-gender groups. Exploring a woman’s journey in Freemasonry within these orders reveals a deep commitment to the Craft’s timeless teachings.
Do traditional male Grand Lodges recognize female Freemasons?
The relationship between traditional male Freemasonry and its female counterparts is one of the most misunderstood aspects of the topic. The key terms are ‘recognition’ and ‘regularity’. In Masonic terms, recognition is a formal acknowledgment that another Grand Lodge adheres to certain standards and traditions, allowing for inter-visitation between their members.
Strictly speaking, mainstream Grand Lodges like the United Grand Lodge of England or the various Grand Lodges in the United States do not formally ‘recognize’ women’s Grand Lodges. This is because the requirement of being male is one of their core ‘landmarks’ or unchangeable tenets. To recognize a body that admits women would be to violate their own constitutions.
However, this lack of formal recognition does not equate to hostility or denial of their existence. In a landmark statement in 1998, the UGLE publicly acknowledged that the two women’s Grand Lodges in the UK, the OWF and HFAF, are regular in their practice. The UGLE stated that while their lodges are for men only, they see these women’s organizations as part of Freemasonry. The statement clarifies that discussions with them have been ‘cordial and constructive’ and that while inter-visitation is not permitted, informal contact on a social level is acceptable. This official position helps the public understand the modern view on women Freemasons from the perspective of the world’s oldest Grand Lodge.
This stance of ‘separate but respected’ is common. Many local lodges share this view, fostering a sense of community even without formal ties. They understand that while their paths are parallel, the destination is the same: to make good people better. This relationship reflects a mature understanding of Freemasonry and women, acknowledging different traditions while respecting a shared heritage and common goals. The landscape is not one of conflict but of mutual respect for different paths.
What does the Masonic journey look like for a woman?
For a woman who joins a Co-Masonic or women’s-only lodge, the journey is remarkably similar to that of a man in a traditional lodge. The experience is centered on a series of allegorical plays or degrees that impart moral and spiritual lessons. Candidates progress through the same three degrees: Entered Apprentice, Fellow Craft, and Master Mason.
The initiation ceremony is a profound and memorable experience. It uses symbolism based on the tools of ancient stonemasons, like the square, compasses, and gavel, to teach virtues such as morality, truth, and integrity. The principles of brotherly love (or fraternal affection), relief (charity), and truth are the bedrock of the experience for all Masons, regardless of gender.
Women Freemasons engage in charitable work, support their communities, and form deep, lifelong friendships with their sisters and brethren. They study Masonic philosophy, history, and symbolism, seeking to improve themselves in mind and spirit. There are numerous female freemason groups and orders, each offering a unique but authentic Masonic home.
The core curriculum of self-discovery and personal growth is universal. The lessons of the level, the plumb rule, and the trowel resonate just as powerfully for women as they do for men. The journey for female freemasons is one of empowerment, enlightenment, and fellowship, proving that the principles of the Craft are truly universal.
Are appendant bodies and other clubs the same as Freemasonry for women?
This is a common point of confusion. There are many organizations connected to Freemasonry that admit women but are not Freemasonry themselves. The most well-known is the Order of the Eastern Star. It is an appendant body, meaning its membership is open to Master Masons and their female relatives.
The Eastern Star has its own beautiful rituals, teachings, and charitable projects. It is a valuable part of the wider Masonic family, but its members are not considered Freemasons. Its purpose is complementary to, not a substitute for, Freemasonry. The same is true for other groups like the Order of the Amaranth or the White Shrine of Jerusalem.
It is also important to distinguish Freemasonry from general service clubs. People sometimes ask, are Rotary Club members Freemasons? While both groups may share members and a commitment to community service, they are entirely separate organizations with different origins, structures, and purposes. Freemasonry’s unique character lies in its specific allegorical system of morality and its deep esoteric traditions.
Recognizing these distinctions is key. The women who join the Order of Women Freemasons, Le Droit Humain, or similar bodies are not joining an auxiliary club. They are being initiated, passed, and raised as Freemasons, undertaking the same work and assuming the same responsibilities as any Mason anywhere in the world.
The world of Freemasonry is far more inclusive than its traditional reputation suggests. The historical male-only structure of mainstream Grand Lodges remains, but it exists alongside a robust and growing Masonic world for women. These are not rival systems but parallel streams flowing from the same ancient source, each seeking to bring light and knowledge to their members.
The journey of women in Freemasonry is a testament to the enduring and universal appeal of the Craft’s core tenets. It is a story of determination, a quest for equality, and a profound dedication to the principles of self-improvement, charity, and fellowship. As society continues to evolve, so too will the face of Freemasonry, forever building a more perfect temple of humanity.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the Order of the Eastern Star a religious or a secret society?
The Order of the Eastern Star is a spiritual organization, but it is not a religion and does not seek to replace a member’s individual faith. Membership requires a belief in a Supreme Being, but it does not prescribe any specific creed or doctrine. The lessons and values are based on stories from the Bible, intended to inspire members to live virtuous and charitable lives in service to others.
Similarly, it is not a secret society but rather a private one with secrets. Its existence, purpose, and places of meeting are all public knowledge, and it proudly supports community initiatives. The "secrets" pertain to its private modes of recognition and the symbolic ceremonies used to teach its lessons, which are reserved for members to preserve the unique experience of joining.
What kind of charitable work does the Order of the Eastern Star do?
Charity is a cornerstone of the Order, with philanthropic efforts organized at multiple levels. On a grand scale, the General Grand Chapter supports major service projects, including funds for cancer research, heart disease, and scholarships for students pursuing religious studies. State-level Grand Chapters often have their own specific charities, such as supporting homes for aged members or funding educational scholarships for local youth.
At the local level, individual chapters are deeply involved in their own communities, making a direct and personal impact. This can include anything from volunteering at food banks and supporting local schools to raising money for a family in need or creating care packages for military service members. This flexibility allows members to address the specific needs they see in their own neighborhoods, making their service both meaningful and effective.
What is the typical time commitment for an Eastern Star member?
The time commitment for a member can be very flexible and is largely based on personal choice. Most local chapters hold one or two "stated" meetings per month, which typically last for a couple of hours. Attending these meetings regularly is the foundation of participation, allowing members to stay connected and take part in the chapter’s business and fellowship.
Beyond regular meetings, the level of involvement is up to the individual member. Opportunities exist to serve on committees, help organize charitable events, or take on a leadership role, which would require a greater time investment. However, many members participate simply by attending meetings and supporting events when their schedule allows, ensuring there is a place for everyone regardless of their available free time.
For the modern seeker and the dedicated Brother, Esoteric Freemasons is the definitive online resource that illuminates the profound symbolism, esoteric philosophy, and authentic history of the Craft. We go beyond the surface to reveal the true light of Masonic knowledge.
